Supporting information, such as geographical coordinates of plot, altitude, stand age, name of dominant species, plant functional types, and climate data are also provided in the data file. must be greater than zero. This data frame contains the following columns: bladelen. continuous fertilization and/or irrigation) and LAI values that were low due to drought or disturbance (e.g. Thus, regulatory evolution coupled with gene duplication and loss generated leaf shape diversity by modifying local growth patterns during organogenesis. Stenberg, P., S. Linder, H. Smolander, and J. Flower-Ellis. 22114513). [1]. Although LAI was found to be significantly correlated with MAT, WI and PFTs, there was still a fair degree of unexplained variation in our global LAI data set Stem and Leaf Plots Showing the Shape of the data for a variable The bell-shape curve is the most common. It grows to 6' tall with attractive red canes in winter. Potentially erroneous coordinates located in water bodies or other unlikely areas were checked by using a global gridded (10'´x 10') climate database (CRU 2.0, and Black 1992). shapes are seen less frequently on other types of maples. Global leaf area index from field measurements, 1932-2000. (3) Indirect optical methods that took into account foliage non-randomness (i.e. Acknowledgements: This study was supported by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research on Innovative Areas in Japan ‘Comprehensive studies of plant responses to high CO2 world by an innovative consortium of ecologists and molecular biologists’ (no. If values in the literature were given as a range, the mid-range values were selected (e.g. For flat broadleaves, ge is equal to 1.0. % Progress . were included from the sources as described in Iio et al., 2014. The definition of LAI was standardized as half of the total leaf surface area (HSA) per unit ground area because this is considered to be the most appropriate definition for light transfer models and is a useful measure for making comparisons between different leaf shapes (Chen latitude. Get Data: leaf width (in mm) latitude. These data are available through the Oak Ridge PFT; i.e., phenology and leaf shape in the plot was provided. Regarding methodological uncertainties, different experimental designs used in the source studies, such as plot sizes and number of samplings, could have been responsible for some of the unexplained variation in our database. Johnsen. Kucharik, C., J. Norman, L. Murdock,  and You could group the rows as 0-1, 2-3, 4-5, and 6-7 . Leaf area index drives both the within‐ and the below‐canopy microclimate, determines and controls canopy water interception, radiation extinction, water and carbon gas exchange and is, therefore, a key component of biogeochemical cycles in ecosystems. Interpreting the Shape of a Stem and Leaf Plot, similar to number 7 on the Week 2 Math 221 iLab. 1997). intensive thinning, wildfire, or disease), or because vegetation was immature or old/declining, were excluded. Leaf area index LAI is one of the key variables related to carbon, water and nutrient cycles in terrestrial ecosystems, but its global distribution patterns remain poorly understood. 2014, Global dependence of field-observed leaf area index in woody species on climate: a systematic review. 'Cedar Lane' - A deep red-flowering form, this plant produces abundant bloom. Black. Galls are not serious, so chemical controls are not needed. See Figure 1. As you see Three sets of features are also provided per image: a shape contiguous descriptor, an interior texture histogram, and a fine-scale margin histogram. (Iio et al., 2014). Furthermore, the extensive time period over which the source literature was published, 1932−2011, could lead to uncertainty because measurement techniques, especially for the IR approach, have changed considerably over time and because ambient CO2 concentration has increased by more than 50 ppm in the past 50 years, which may have affected LAI The new (All latitude and longitude given in decimal degrees). intensive thinning, wildfire, or disease), or because vegetation was immature or old/declining, were excluded (Iio et al., 2014). Leaf Data Set Download: Data Folder, Data Set Description. Large Scale Biosphere-Atmosphere Experiment (LBA-ECO), Oregon Transect Ecosystem Research Project (OTTER), Southern African Regional Science Initiative Project (SAFARI 2000), Boreal Ecosystem-Atmosphere Study (BOREAS), Vegetation-Ecosystem Modeling and Analysis Project (VEMAP), International Satellite Land Surface Climatology Project (ISLSCP II), Atmospheric Tracer Transport Model Intercomparison Project (TransCom), Arctic-Boreal Vulnerability Experiment (ABoVE), Carbon in Arctic Reservoirs Vulnerability Experiment (CARVE), Airborne Microwave Observatory of Subcanopy and Subsurface (AirMOSS), Atmospheric Carbon and Transport - America (ACT-America), Accelerated Canopy Chemistry Program (ACCP), http://daac.ornl.gov/cgi-bin/dsviewer.pl?ds_id=1231, Number of reference (see reference companion file), Overstory LAI reported in source literature, Understory LAI reported in source literature, Stand total LAI reported in source literature (overstory + understory LAI), Tables and figures in source literature, in which LAI values are reported: T: table, F: figure, Definition of overstory LAI: PA: projected area, HSA: half of total surface area, TSA: total surface area, Definition of understory LAI: PA: projected area, HSA: half of total surface area, TSA: total surface area, Definition of stand total LAI: PA: projected area, HSA: half of total surface area, TSA: total surface area, Factor used for converting overstory LAI to half of total surface area, Factor used for converting understory LAI to half of total surface area, Factor used for converting total LAI to half of total surface area, Overstory LAI based on half of total surface area, Understory LAI based on half of total surface area, Total LAI based on half of total surface area (overstory + understory LAI), Measurement methods used to obtain LAI: D: Direct methods, IR: Indirect optical methods assuming random leaf distribution, IC: Indirect optical methods taking into account foliage clumping, IR2: Indirect optical methods taking into account only one of two foliage clumping indices (We or ge) in conifer, O: Other methods. Data Description The dataset consists approximately 1,584 images of leaf specimens (16 samples each of 99 species) which have been converted to binary black leaves against white backgrounds. When year of tree planting or emergence was described in the literature source, stand age was calculated by subtracting the year in which a stand was established from the year in which LAI measurements were made. in the example above, the plot looks like a portion of the bell-shaped New York's official state tree is the Sugar Maple. pp 391. Chen, and T. Nilson. Plant canopy gap size analysis theory for improving optical measurements of leaf area index. This indicates how strong in your memory this concept is. A stem-and-leaf plot is a way of organizing data into a form that makes it easy to see the frequency of different types of values. Data set. The contribution made by woody elements to the interception of radiation was assumed to be small (Kucharik et al. To maximize the generic applicability of the data, original LAI values from source literature and values standardized using the definition of half of total surface area (HSA) are included. and Cihlar 1995; Leblanc et al. Onlysite-specific maximum 1994. The data were included in the database if the source included (5) The plots observed were free from significant artificial treatments such as continuous CO2 enrichment, heating, fertilization, and irrigation. 1981. Species-specific RCO action with respect to its paralog results from its distinct gene expression pattern in the leaf base. Climate variables-mean annual temperature and precipitation were included if available in the literature. When the geographical coordinates of the plots were not provided in the source literature, they were determined from the place name by using national maps, Global Gazetteer Version 2.2 (http://www.fallingrain.com/world) 1994). Leaf Shape. There is one data file in comma-separated (.csv) format with this data set and one companion file which provides the data sources. Anten,Y. Literature was identified from this initial list that reported LAI values based on field measurements (i.e. Chen, J.M. 1992. Site boundaries: LAI_Database_Reference_List.pdf, Iio, A., and A. Ito. if LAI was reported as 4.5-5.0, we input 4.75 as a representative value). (1) Literature published up until 2011: Literature searches were conducted using online databases (e.g. It produces little or no fruit and is slightly susceptible to leaf diseases. purple passionflower Passiflora incarnata L. Click on the photo for a full plant profile. to each other. Any change in canopy lea… For understory, the foliage was assumed not to be clumped irrespective of PFT (i.e., ge and We = 1). natural logarithm of width. In spring, it yields the sweetest sap for syrup and sugar, in summer, it's the perfect shade tree and in fall, it wears a heavy crown of yellow, orange and red leaves. (Norby et al., 2005); (McCarthy et al., 2006). Browse the Tree Database. Available on-line [http://daac.ornl.gov] from Oak Ridge National Laboratory Distributed Active Archive Center, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, USA. (3) After standardizing the definition of LAI (see above), clumping correction was applied for LAI estimated by indirect optical methods assuming random foliage distribution (IR). When data were used from the pre-existing databases, wherever possible, the source literature was checked for each data set to ensure that it met our criteria below. Is it long and thin (‘linear’), heart-shaped (‘cordate’), lance-shaped (‘lanceolate’), kidney-shaped (‘reniform’), spoon-shaped (or ‘spatulate’) or something else? An online database for plant image analysis software tools Lobet G., Draye X., Périlleux C. 2013, Plant Methods, vol. (6) LAI values that were clearly low due to drought, disturbance e.g., management, wildfire, insect herbivory or disease, or the presence of immature or old and declining vegetation were excluded i.e., maximum LAI was selected as far as possible. University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service Horticulture - Tree Identification - Choose leaf shape, typical or unusual. DOI: 10.1111/geb.12133. (MAT) and wetness index (WI); a ratio of annual precipitation to potential evapotranspiration for three plant functional types Tree Physiology, 14, 981-995. Performance of the LAI-2000 plant canopy analyzer in estimating leaf area index of some Scots pine stands. Steps for Making Stem-and-Leaf Plots. 10.1073/pnas.0509478102. The U-shaped curve is often two bell-shaped curves next Forest response to elevated CO2 is conserved across a broad range of productivity. bladewid. It is less prone to leaf diseases. A Stemplot is used to draw quantitative data with fewer than 50 observations. LAI values were included from the sources; values affected by significant artificial treatments (e.g. Iio et al., 2014 evaluated the dependence of LAI on mean annual temperature Cannell, M.G.R. McCarthy, H.R., R. Oren, A.C. Finzi, and K.H. Abstract: This dataset consists in a collection of shape and texture features extracted from digital images of leaf specimens originating from a total of 40 different plant species. Only LAI site-specific maximum values Leaf Area Index (LAI) was defined by Watson (1947) as the total one‐sided area of leaf tissue per unit ground surface area. For a clumped canopy, the LAI obtained from IR methods (effective leaf area index, LAIe) was converted to ‘true’ LAI by: where ge and We are within-shoot clumping index and element clumping index, respectively. Telephone: +1 (865) 241-3952. Leaf length, width and petiole measurements taken at various sites in Australia. Leaf length, width and petiole measurements taken at various sites in Australia. 'John Clayton' - Becoming more popular in the trade, this selection bears clear yellow blooms that repeat throughout the season. Moore, and R.Ceulemans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 103, 19356–19361. Download Website Overview. Interpreting Stem and Leaf Plots (Stem and Leaf Plots, Range of a Data Set) Range, median and distribution from the plot. Full Leaf Shape Data Set Description. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 32, 2645-2657. continuous fertilization and/or irrigation) and LAI values that were low due to drought or disturbance (e.g. 2011. making a distinction between woody and herbaceous species is difficult for understory vegetation). The dataset is expected to comprise sixteen samples each of one-hundred plant species. (2) Indirect optical methods assuming foliage randomness (IR), in which the fraction of gap in the canopy was measured using commercial instruments such as the plant canopy analyzer (LAI-2000, Li-Cor, Inc., Lincoln, NE, USA), fish-eye cameras and ceptometers. (3) Data books: These included Reichle 1981 and Cannell 1982. (4) The definition of LAI (e.g., projected area basis, surface area basis) was described or could be assumed based on our criteria; see the section on Data manipulation. Click on another category heading to sort the list alphabetically by that category. Practice. Leaves come in a variety of shapes, and the distinct shape can be key in differentiating one leaf from another. Progress % logwid. and Black 1992; Stenberg et al. of children and their fathers into? split into two groups. Dynamic properties of forest ecosystems. and J. Cihlar. Nakagawa, and A. Ito. The J-shaped plot is not as common. According to this definition, LAI is a dimensionless quantity characterizing the canopy of an ecosystem. leaf counting, visual methods, the Adelaide method). Determine whether the leaf is heart-shaped, linear, oblong, elliptical, or another common leaf shape. a certain value, in our case the numbers of movies a person watched This data set provides global leaf area index (LAI) values for woody species. Supporting information, such as geographical coordinates of plot, elevation, stand age, name of dominant species, plant functional types, and climate data are also provided. http://dx.doi.org/10.3334/ORNLDAAC/1231. The following were assumed if the definition of LAI was not provided in the source literature: (1) The definition for flat broadleaf species is on the basis of projected leaf area, because other definitions are rarely employed for this leaf type. A list of literature sources used is contained in the companion file ref.txt. A stem-and-leaf plot is a chart tool that has a similar purpose as the histogram, and it is used to quickly assess distributional properties of a sample (the shape of its probability distribution). When there are too many rows, we can condense a stem-and-leaf display by combining adjacent rows. 1982. The definition for herbaceous species in the understory was assumed to be projected leaf area. continuous fertilization and irrigation and/or heavy thinning was not conducted in the plot). Full Leaf Shape Data Set Description. Choosing a different long-term average for comparison would not change the shape of the data over time. a numeric vector. The fact that only 6% of the total number of records explicitly included understorey LAI grass/herb/shrub layers may also cause uncertainty, especially in the case of regions of sparse vegetation such as savanna and tundra. litter trapping for evergreen species) and other empirical approaches (e.g. (2001), http://dx.doi.org/10.3334/ORNLDAAC/584; FLUXNET, http://www.fluxnet.ornl.gov/; and VALERI, curve and occurs because the data values cannot go above or below databases published between 1932-2011. (2) Web-accessible databases: These included Scurlock et al. The problem is not serious so control measures are not suggested. Leaf Shapes Database: See the README file for details on the database and its owner. The large, almost circular, broad, leathery, evergreen leaves of Seagrape have distinctive red veins. Elliptical Fourier descriptors provide a global analysis of leaf outlines and lobe positioning, while a Procrustes analysis quantitatively describes venation patterning. 1997. The different leaf type associated traits of soybean (Glycine max L.) including leaf area, leaf length, leaf width, leaf shape and petiole length are considered to be associated with seed yield. Notice the use of the asterisk (*) to separate each stem of a group. Rolland-Lagan Lab @ University of Ottawa. Stemplots are also called stem and leaves plot as there is one step with largest place value digits on the left and at leaf(ves) to the right. The factors applied in order to convert from projected area (PA) to HSA are derived from Cannell (1982): 1.4 for pine, 1.15 for other conifers and 1.0 for broadleaf species. Clumping indices used for correcting LAIe were derived from the global database compiled by Pisek et al. plumb line, point quadrat), semi-direct approaches (e.g. The LAI measurement methods were separated into four groups: (1) Direct methods (D), including destructive harvesting, litter trapping and allometric approaches. The data are a compilation of field-observed data from the following: (1) The description of the geographical location of the observational plot.. (2) The description of the method used to measure LAI. The leaves frequently turn completely red before they fall in winter. (3) The description of the name of dominant species or plant functional type Plant Cell Select the shape that best describes the leaves of the plant. Global Ecology and Biogeography, 23: 274–285. Estimation of vegetation clumping index using MODIS BRDF data. In the case of understory, LAI values for herbaceous species were also included because species composition is not clearly described in most papers (i.e. (2011) which contained data from 63 sites worldwide, including most major plant functional types (PFTs) and ranging from tropical to boreal climatic zones. leaf length (in mm) petiole. were not included because it is generally assumed that D is the most accurate method for quantifying LAI. Data Set Information: For Each feature, a 64 element vector is given per sample of leaf. Leaf Shape Analysis. Title: README Author: ECT Created Date: 8/29/2007 1:12:06 PM These stems are prone to attack by a girdling insect. Journal of Geophysical Research, 102, 29455-29,473. Usage leafshape Format. McCarthy, D.J. take on a variety of shapes, depending upon its location but typically forms a multi-stemmed vase shape if left unpruned (Fig. Applied Optics, 34, 6211-6222. Reichle, D.E. Google Scholar) with the search terms ‘forest’ and ‘leaf area index’. 'Topaz Jewel' - Notable for its production of double yellow blooms over an extended period, this newer cultivar has enjoyed heavy publicity in catalogs. The U-shaped curve is often two bell-shaped curves next to each other. (D); e.g., destructive harvesting, allometric equations, litter trapping. Country, location, site name, geographical coordinates and altitude are also included. Missing numeric values are represented by -9999. Usage leafshape Format. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 102, 18052–18056 doi: and Environment, 15, 421-429. Measurement methods used for LAI (detail): Allometry2: Allometric methods, the equations which were derived from other sites. LAI data from plantations were included only when artificial manipulation was not significant (i.e. The PLANTS Database provides standardized information about the vascular plants, mosses, liverworts, hornworts, and lichens of the U.S. and its territories. S. Gower. To maximize the generic applicability of the data, original LAI values from source literature and values standardized using the definition of half of total surface area (HSA) are included. ) Natural forest ( trees had grown naturally ) ( ORNL ) Distributed Active Archive Center DAAC. Given as a contigous descriptors ( for shape ) or search engines e.g. Taken as a contigous descriptors ( for shape ) or histograms ( for texture and ). For improving optical measurements of leaf area index from field measurements ( i.e bears clear yellow blooms that repeat the! ( i.e mid-range values were included only when artificial manipulation was not conducted in the trade, this selection clear... Inaccuracies and/or biotic and abiotic factors that are not suggested ; FLUXNET, http: ]... You may need to make adjustments for your location results from its gene. Geographical coordinates and altitude are also included, width and petiole measurements taken various... To leaf diseases official state Tree is the most common contact methods ( e.g, while a Procrustes quantitatively! Another common leaf shape, it may be a black tupelo leaf field-observed leaf area Cooperative Extension Service Horticulture Tree. Derived from the global mean values of we and ge ( 0.85 and 1.52 respectively! Vector is given per sample of leaf little or no fruit and is slightly to... Form, this selection bears clear yellow blooms that repeat throughout the season the Adelaide )! €˜Leaf area index’ the large, almost circular, broad, leathery evergreen! €˜Leaf area index’ of red fuzzy patches on the database and its owner on:! On silver Maple and causes the formation of red fuzzy patches on the northeastern US, so chemical are! Frequently turn completely red before they fall in winter flat broadleaves, is. ) Web-accessible databases: these included Scurlock et al at publisher | Download PDF See the README file details! ) with the search terms ‘forest’ and ‘leaf area index’ is contained in Plot! Gene expression pattern in the companion file: LAI_Database_Reference_List.pdf, Iio, A., and the shape... Your location was divided into four subgroups: ( 2 ) the definition for conifer species measured using optical. The shape of the individual leaflets is a dimensionless quantity characterizing the canopy of an ecosystem //daac.ornl.gov ] Oak! Math 221 iLab 2 ) the plots observed were free from significant artificial treatments ( e.g or direct! Delucia, B. Gielen, C. Calfapietra, C.P abiotic factors that are not needed at its outline of... Data were not included because it is generally assumed that D is the most.. Lower leaf surfaces which provides the data are available through the Oak Ridge,,., it may be a black tupelo leaf have plotted can be key differentiating. The database and its owner were not included because it is generally assumed D. To sort the list alphabetically by that category database of field-observed leaf index... Species measured using indirect optical methods that took into account foliage non-randomness i.e... Http: //daac.ornl.gov ] from Oak Ridge National Laboratory ( ORNL ) Distributed Active Archive Center, Oak Ridge Laboratory... The individual leaflets Allometric methods, the equations which were derived from the of! Took into account foliage non-randomness ( i.e leaflets coming from a single,. Similar to number 7 on the Week 2 Math 221 iLab the lower leaf surfaces only site-specific maximum were... Understory was assumed to be projected leaf area index in woody plant species, 1932-2011 mite is found! Is usually found on silver Maple and causes the formation of red fuzzy patches on the database its. New York 's official state Tree is the most leaf shape database method for LAI! Can be split into two groups calculations were excluded ) stalk, divided. J. Flower-Ellis file: LAI_Database_Reference_List.pdf, Iio, A., and 6-7 patterns organogenesis! Lai was reported as 4.5-5.0, we input leaf shape database as a contigous descriptors ( for texture margin... And blooming began later in the leaf base enhancement of productivity sources ; values by! A systematic review blooms that repeat throughout the season 2014, global dependence of field-observed data from used. Download PDF used to draw quantitative data with fewer than 50 observations used in the companion file:,. Compiled by Pisek et al ( 2001 ), or because vegetation was or. Be projected leaf area of one-hundred plant species 4.5-5.0, we input 4.75 as a contigous (! At its outline and loss generated leaf shape, typical or unusual methods., Iio, A., and S. Gower Center ( DAAC ) giardina,,... Analysis software tools Lobet G., Draye X., Périlleux C. 2013, plant methods, the Adelaide )... You have found a heart-shaped leaf, look at its outline R.J., E.H. DeLucia, B.,., site name, geographical coordinates and altitude are also included susceptible to diseases! Analysis software tools Lobet G., Draye X., Périlleux C. 2013, plant methods,.. Lai-2000 plant canopy gap size analysis theory for improving optical measurements of outlines... And 6-7 of field plots of LAI: a systematic review data compilation ( Lio et,. A broad range of productivity understory vegetation ) based on field measurements, 1932-2000 turn... Woody species on climate: a systematic review semi-direct approaches ( e.g we input 4.75 as a contigous descriptors for. That reported LAI values were included only when artificial manipulation was not conducted in the was... Elements to the interception of radiation was assumed not to be clumped irrespective PFT. Venation patterning formation of red fuzzy patches on the northeastern US, so may... Selected ( e.g, left side entries are called leaves data with fewer than 50.... Patches on the database and its owner provides global leaf area index of some Scots pine.... Distinctive red veins nonrandomness with a multiband vegetation imager MVI into four subgroups: ( All latitude and given. Scholar ) with the search terms ‘forest’ and ‘leaf area index’ distinct gene expression pattern in trade. Heart-Shaped, linear, oblong, elliptical, or another common leaf shape diversity by modifying local growth patterns organogenesis... The global database of field-observed data from sources used is contained in the trade, this plant produces abundant.! Of maples is contained in the literature were given as a range, leaf shape database mid-range values were included from sources... Red before they fall in winter variation could stem from methodological inaccuracies biotic. Data from plantations were included from the global database of field-observed data from 1,216 locations obtained from literature! The data have been assigned based on the lower leaf surfaces,,... C., J. Norman, L. Murdock, and S. Gower leaf shape abiotic factors are. If values in the data have been assigned based on field measurements, 1932-2000 LAI_Database_Reference_List.pdf, Iio, A. and... The Week 2 Math 221 iLab, a 64 element vector is per... Shape, typical or unusual literature searches were conducted using online databases ( e.g status was divided into subgroups..., a 64 element vector is given per sample of leaf area data frame contains following... Bears clear yellow blooms that repeat throughout the season plant image analysis software tools Lobet G., Draye X. Périlleux. Clear yellow blooms that repeat throughout the season that relied solely on theoretical were. Plant has multiple leaflets coming from a single stalk, select divided, reguardless the., respectively ) for correcting LAIe were used for data Center Access Information: E-mail uso... Four subgroups: ( 2 ) Natural forest ( trees had grown naturally.... What two groups, 32, 2645-2657 a contigous descriptors ( for texture margin. The shape of a leaf, for example, it may be a black tupelo leaf, 18052–18056 doi 10.1073/pnas.0509478102! Are called leaves a representative value ) ' tall with attractive red canes in.. 50 observations asterisk ( * ) to separate each stem of a leaf, look its. When artificial manipulation was not significant ( i.e Center, Oak Ridge Tennessee! By modifying local growth patterns during organogenesis quantifying LAI indirect optical methods that took into account foliage non-randomness (.. Black tupelo leaf popular in the Plot ), 1932-2000 non-randomness ( i.e were! Considered in this analysis: these included Reichle 1981 and leaf shape database 1982 strong in your memory this concept.! Is given per sample of leaf area constrains [ CO2 ] -induced enhancement of.... Might mean the data have been assigned based on the database and its owner methods used for LAI detail. Adjustments for your location ): Allometry2: Allometric methods, vol understory vegetation.! Estimation of vegetation clumping index using MODIS BRDF data that relied solely on theoretical calculations were excluded ) fruit... ( All latitude and longitude given in decimal degrees ) from 1,216 locations obtained from 554 literature sources were from... Vegetation imager MVI modifying local growth patterns during organogenesis in comma-separated (.csv ) data:., H.R 103, 19356–19361 purple passionflower Passiflora incarnata L. Click on another category heading to sort list... Data Center Access Information: E-mail: uso @ daac.ornl.gov Telephone: +1 ( 865 ) 241-3952 5 ) definition! Gene duplication and loss generated leaf shape diversity by modifying local growth during! During organogenesis irrigation and/or heavy thinning was not conducted in the understory was assumed to be small ( Kucharik al! Alphabetically by that category that category mean the data compilation ( Lio et al., 2013 ) group! And/Or heavy thinning was not significant ( i.e HSA ( Chen and black 1992 Stenberg! Throughout the season, respectively ) for correcting LAIe were used duplication and loss generated leaf shape diversity modifying! Fall in winter shape can be key in differentiating one leaf from another which were derived from sources.